2.
Response
to
Comments
2.9
Individual
Responses
to
Comments
from
Organizations
The
Machinery
&
Equipment
Building,
located
to
the
south
of
the
Roundhouse,
was
identified
in
the
Draft
EIR
as
a
historical
resource
for
CEQA
purposes.
The
Lazzari
Charcoal
Building
/
Tank
and
Boiler
Shop,
located
to
the
north
of
the
Roundhouse,
was
evaluated
and
determined
ineligible
for
listing
as
a
historic
resource.
Please
see
Draft
EIR
page
4.D-17
which
provides
a
full
description
and
evaluation
of
this
building.
Please
see
which
notes
that
only
the
Roundhouse
and
the
Machinery
&
Equipment
Building
were
identified
as
historical
resources,
and
that
all
other
buildings
or
structures
were
evaluated
but
found
ineligible
for
listing
as
historical
resources
because
they
did
not
meet
the
standard
state
and
federal
evaluation
criteria.
The
Roundhouse
turntable,
as
well
as
the
vast
majority
of
the
former
railyard
tracks,
poles,
lights,
and
other
hardware
are
no
longer
extant
at
the
Baylands
Project
Site
and
thus
do
not
meet
CRHR
eligibility
criteria
1
–
4
either
individually,
or
as
part
of
a
district.
Mitigation
Measure
4.D-1a
on
Draft
EIR
pages
4.D-27
-
28
states
that
“[t]he
rehabilitation
plans
shall
meet
a
minimum
of
7
out
of
10
of
the
standards.”
Draft
EIR
page
4.D-23
notes
that
a
project
that
follows
the
Secretary
of
the
Interior’s
Standards
for
the
Treatment
of
Historic
Properties
with
Guidelines
for
Preserving,
Rehabilitating,
Restoring,
and
Reconstructing
Historic
Buildings
or
the
Secretary
of
the
Interior’s
Standards
for
Rehabilitation
and
Guidelines
for
Rehabilitating
Historic
Buildings,
is
considered
to
have
mitigated
a
significant
impact
on
the
historical
resource
to
a
less-than-
significant
level.
While
there
is
no
specific
number
of
Standards
that
a
project
should
meet,
accepted
industry
practice
means
that
a
project
should
meet
‘most’
or
approximately
7
out
of
the
10
Standards
for
Rehabilitation.
For
example,
the
project
should
meet
Standard
#1
which
states
that
a
property
will
be
used
as
it
was
historically
or
be
given
a
new
use
that
requires
minimal
change
to
its
distinctive
materials,
features,
spaces,
and
spatial
relationships.
The
project
should
also
meet
Standard
#6,
which
states
that
deteriorated
historic
features
will
be
repaired
rather
than
replaced,
and
where
the
severity
of
deterioration
requires
replacement
of
a
distinctive
feature,
the
new
feature
will
match
the
old
in
design,
color,
texture,
and,
where
possible,
materials.
9
Finally,
the
project
should
also
meet
Standards
2,
5,
7,
9,
and
10.
Mitigation
Measure
4.D-1
is
adequate
to
reduce
the
impacts
to
the
Roundhouse
resulting
from
rehabilitation
to
a
less-than-
significant
level.
Draft
EIR
pages
4.D-2–3
note
that
site
P-41-000496
is
a
large
midden
site
that
included
human
burials.
The
site
was
9
http://www.nps.gov/tps/standards/four-treatments/treatment-rehabilitation.htm
Brisbane
Baylands
Final
EIR
2.9.2-72
May
2015